In Transboundary Aquifers Agreements: Which States Can Become Parties?

One question often arises in transboundary groundwater negotiations: not where the aquifer is located, but which States have a legally relevant relationship with the aquifer and may participate in the agreement.

At first sight, the answer may appear straightforward: the parties should be the Aquifer States, the States in whose territories the transboundary aquifer or aquifer system is situated.

However, the legal framework for transboundary aquifers reveals a more nuanced picture.

1. Aquifer States:

An Aquifer State is a State in whose territory any part of a transboundary aquifer or aquifer system is situated.

These States have the most direct territorial relationship with the groundwater resource and are the principal States addressed by the cooperation framework of the 2008 Draft Articles on the Law of Transboundary Aquifers.

Articles 7, 8, and 9, in particular, establish important foundations for cooperation and the conclusion of regional agreements and arrangements concerning the management of particular transboundary aquifers or aquifer systems.

2. Recharge or Discharge States:

The more difficult legal question arises where a State contains a recharge or discharge zone, while no part of the aquifer or aquifer system itself is situated in that State.

This is not merely a hydrological distinction. Article 11(2) of the 2008 Draft Articles expressly recognizes such a State and imposes a duty of cooperation on it, requiring the State to cooperate with the Aquifer States to protect the aquifer or aquifer system and related ecosystems.

This distinction is particularly important when drafting an agreement, where it determines many things, such as:

– The scope of transboundary aquifer agreements.
– States’ rights to conclude regional agreements and arrangements.
– The rights of States entitled to join a joint management mechanism.
– Monitoring and information-sharing mechanisms.
– Protection measures for recharge and discharge zones.
– The respective rights and obligations of participating States.

The effectiveness of a groundwater agreement relies on both aquifer-sharing States and those performing hydrological functions.
Moreover, hydrological connections to international watercourses may bring the aquifer within the scope of the 1997 UN Convention.

However, should the legal rights and obligations of a Recharge or Discharge State differ from those of an Aquifer State in a groundwater agreement?

I welcome thoughts and insights from peers specializing in transboundary water management and international water law

#InternationalWaterLaw #TransboundaryGroundwater #TransboundaryAquifers #GroundwaterLaw #InternationalLaw #WaterLaw #GroundwaterGovernance #TransboundaryWaterGovernance #WaelFathy #DrWaelFathy #WaelMohamedFathy

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *